Predisposing Factors


Written by: Fabio Piccini, doctor and Jungian psychotherapist, in charge of the "Centre for Eating Disorders Therapy" at "Malatesta Novello" nursing home in Cesena. Works privately in Rimini and Chiavari. E-mail: piccini@anoressia-bulimia.it
First version: 26 Nov 2006. Latest revision: 26 Nov 2006.

Question(s):
Which factors make it more likely that a person will get an eating disorder?

Answer:

Research on eating disorders has shown that it is not possible to attribute only one cause to an eating disorder development.

Eating disorder development has been described as a three-phase process where the presence of certain risk factors creates a predisposition to fall ill; for this reason some people become more vulnerable to eating disorder development.
When these more vulnerable people have to face up to very stressful events, there is a high probability that they will develop an eating disorder rather than psychological, psychosomatic or other kinds of pathology.

When the eating disorder is stable, it is prone to self-maintenance.

There are different factors that predispose people to develop an eating disorder. Some predisposing factors are:

* Being a woman. It is undeniable that a woman is more subject to the slimness cult than a man.
* Being between the ages of 15 and 35. Eating disorders reach their peak in this age bracket.
* Suffering from depressive disorders and having particular personality traits.
* Being overweight. It has been noticed that many eating disorders begin with a strict diet in overweight people.
* Having a family where weight and body fitness are considered important problems.
* Having been victims of sexual abuse during childhood and adolescence. An incidence of abuse victims is of statistical importance in eating disorder patients.
* Growing up in a family that had not transmitted enough self-esteem, trust in oneself and the capacity to recognize and elaborate emotions.

The presence of two or more factors will create in people a predisposition to suffer from eating disorders that will be stronger as the factors increase.

Difference between People with Eating Disorders and Other People; Comfort by Eating (or by Starving)

Written by: Gunborg Palme, certified psychologist and certified psychotherapist, teacher and tutor in psychotherapy.

In what way are people with eating disorders different from other people? Are these differences the causes of eating disorders? Do they get comfort by eating, even when they do not need more nutrition?

Answer:

People with eating disorders experience that they are not in control of their needs and impulses. Rather they feel controlled by forces outside themselves. If you look at the story of their lives, certain phenomena recur. When they were children, the surrounding people have not responded in an adequate way to the signals which expresses needs or feelings. If the surrounding environment does not understand the child's true needs and take proper action, the child is inhibited in learning to be more conscious of its needs.

Either people with eating disorders don't feel the body signals for hunger and satisfaction, or they don't listen to these signals. They eat for reasons other than physical hunger, for example, they are tired, stressed or feel melancholy. Their relation to food makes them unhappy and they are not being able to cope with food in a proper way.

People without eating disorders are in contact with their physical feelings of hunger and satisfaction, and use those feelings when they decide when and how much to eat. They generally eat for no other reasons than hunger, and need food to be satisfied. Eating is satisfying and works smoothly like breathing and sleeping.


Disturbed Eating

Normal Eating




What controls eating?

Eating is separated from its normal control by hunger, appetite and satisfaction. It can be controlled by the will, planned diet, counting of calories, feelings, appearance and food odour.

Eating is controlled by hunger, appetite and satisfaction. A person eats when in need of nutrition and stops when satisfied; is usually hungry at mealtimes.

Why a person eats:

Often for other reasons than nutritional needs: to alter the figure, to reduce pain, stress, anguish, anger, loneliness and melancholy.

There are unpleasant physical feelings after excessive eating together with regret, guilt and shame.

For nutrition, health and energy. Also for pleasure and as a part of social company. Normal eating gives a feeling of satisfaction.

When a person eats:

Eating is irregular and chaotic - often too much or too little.

Regular habits. Usually three meals a day and small snacks between them if needed.

What controls eating?

For a healthy person, eating is controlled by feelings of true hunger, appetite and satisfaction. You eat when you need nourishment and stop eating when you are satisfied.

A person with eating disorders lacks the normal connection between the nutritional need of the body and the hunger signals. Eating is determined by will, planned diet, counting calories and if you are tempted by delicious food.

Why a person eats.

A healthy person eats for nourishment, health and energy, but sometimes also for pleasure or as an part of a social event. You feel content when you eat.

For people with eating disorders, eating is governed by the will to change the appearance of the body, or to reduce pain, stress, anxiety, loneliness, monotony, etc. After completing the meal, they feel discomfort and remorse, guilt and shame.

When a person eats.

The healthy person eats regularly, for example, three main courses and snacks according to what the body craves.

A person with an eating disorder eats irregularly and chaotic - sometimes too much, sometimes too little. Sometimes you skip a meal, sometimes you fast, sometimes you overeat and sometimes you diet. It's common to either eat too much or too little.

Normal eating: You have contact with your body's physical sensations of hunger and satisfaction, and use it to decide when and how much to eat. You normally do not eat for other reasons than that you are hungry and need nourishment. You get satisfied with eating and eating works by itself like breathing and sleeping.

Disturbed eating: Either you cannot feel your body's signals for hunger and satisfaction, or you can feel them, but you disregard them. In both cases, you eat for other reasons than need of nourishment, such as stress or sadness. You are unhappy with your relation to food and cannot resolve it in a sensible way.

Causes of Eating Disorders and Obesity in Children and Adults


Written by: Gunborg Palme, certified psychologist and certified psychotherapist, teacher and tutor in psychotherapy.

First version: 26 Nov 2006. Latest revision: 04 Jul 2007.


Question(s):


What are the causes of eating disorders and obesity in Children and Adults?

Answer:

There are various contributory causes of eating disorders and often several of these may act in combination.

* The ability to distinguish between hunger, satisfaction and other feelings is learned when one is very young. Faulty upbringing can interfere with this. The effect is often not noticed until later in life.

* Eating disorders often arise when a person tries to reduce to an abnormally low weight. The unnatural slim ideal may be therefore a contributory cause of eating disorders.


* Many people with eating disorders are not aware of their physical feelings of hunger and satisfaction. Thus, they lack a natural control of their eating. Such people will easier be pulled into eating disorders, where they use eating to conceal feelings and escape from constructive problem solutions.


* Both overeating and fasting can stimulate the reward centre in the brain. Eating disorders therefore function in the same way as alcoholism and drug addiction. The same personality traits which increase the risk of alcoholism and drug addiction also increase the risk of eating disorders.

* The personality traits which increase the risk of eating disorders are partly hereditary. Addictive problems or affective disorders (depression, etc.) are more common among relatives.


* Some of the personality traits involved are: a tendency to please others and a low ability to assert one's own needs; a need to reduce unsettling feelings of anxiety, depression and low self-confidence; perfectionism and problems with impulse control. More about personality.


* Eating disorders are more common among women and those who are affected by social attitudes and body ideals and who also lack the ability of following their own feelings and needs.


* Children of overweight parents, and parents with an exaggerated interest in body shape, more often get eating disorders. Also, demands from the family and insecure family circumstances increase the risk.


Overweight occurs if you eat more fat than your body can consume. Both biological (somatic) and life-style factors can cause overweight. Eating disorders (see above) can also cause overweight. There are also some illnesses and drugs which can make a person more susceptible to overweight.

Causes of Addiction and Eating Disorders


Written by: Gunborg Palme First version: 26 Nov 2006. Latest revision: 14 Sep 2007.

Question(s):


Is there any connection between eating disorders, alcoholism, smoking and drug addiction? Are the causes of anorexia, bulimia and binge eating the same as the causes for alcoholism, smoking and other addictions?


Answer:

Research on eating disorders has shown that there are similarities between many cases of eating disorders and addictive conditions such as alcoholism and drug addiction. The human brain has special reward centres and these are normally activated when a person feels well, takes care of the body, behaves sensibly, is praised, is in love, exercises, etc. More.

It is also possible to stimulate these reward centers by artificial means. Drugs of all kinds forbidden and permitted, produce chemical stimulation which is an important part of the cause of addiction. Stimulation also blocks unpleasant feelings and therefore those with eating disorders, as well as those with other addictive disorders, may use them to block unbearable feelings.

Normal people get their stimulation of the reward center by doing good things. They are stimulated by exercise because it is good for the body to get exercise. They are stimulated by eating, because it is good for the body to get nourishment. They are stimulated by being in love, because it is good for the survival of the human race that people mate. They are stimulated when they have achieved something or when they get appraisal because it is good that people do constructive things.

However, if the reward centre is stimulated by drugs, alcohol or abuse of food, they cease to function in the way they should. Abuse is a short cut to false happiness, a happiness which doesn't come from doing something good.

Incorrect usage of the reward centres is especially common with people who have a personality requiring a lot of reward effects in order for them to feel well, and also have worry and stress which can be reduced by drugs.

There is accordingly a common factor with many types of addiction:

  • Alcoholism and drug disorders
  • Eating disorders
  • Compulsive sex dependence
  • Compulsive gambling
  • Compulsive exercising
  • Self-injury and anorexia nervosa (even body injury can stimulate the reward centre in order to protect the body from pain).

This means that much of what is known about the treatment of alcoholism and drug addiction can be used for eating disorders. The patient's own ego must be strengthened and taught to refuse the kind of eating pattern which tempts with quick artificial solutions.


A similarity between eating disorders and drug addiction is that the addiction is compulsively developed into an even stronger form regardless of the effect on the patient's health. Despite serious medical complications, it is difficult for addicts to give up their addiction. Starvation in anorexia reduces the activity of the hormone Serotonin and this in turn reduces anxiety in a patient with an overactive nervous system. Patients with anorexia are, less often than others, drug addicts and alcoholics while those with other eating disorders more often are so. Those anorectics who alternate between eating attacks and starvation are more like bulimics.

Research shows, for example, that personality types that more often feel stress and anxiety, need more stimulation in order to feel well.

Research also shows that those with eating disorders often have excessively low values for dopamine and CSF-5-HIAA as well as Serotonin which causes them to feel more stressed than others and that many drug addicts began with compulsive eating before going over to drugs and furthermore that certain hereditary characteristics increase the risk of eating disorders and drug addiction.

However, everybody with these hereditary characteristics does not become an addict as there are other ways of managing the problem, e.g., medicine which stabilises the concentration of Serotonin in the brain may help (in combination with other treatment) those who have eating disorders.

Anorexia Can Give You a Feeling of Satisfaction


Written by: Gunborg Palme, certified psychologist and certified psychotherapist, teacher and tutor in psychotherapy.
First version: 27 Nov 2006. Latest revision: 25 Jul 2007.

Question(s):

Is anorexia similar to drug addiction?

Answer:

People who fast can get high from starvation. Many anorectics describe how starvation reduces psychic anguish and how the anxiety returns when they begin to eat again. It seems as if anorexia stimulates those substances in the brain which affect the pleasure and reward centre, and thereby enables them to control and avoid psychic anguish in the same way as alcoholics and drug addicts do.

Anorectics May Think They are Fat

Written by: Gunborg Palme, certified psychologist and certified psychotherapist, teacher and tutor in psychotherapy.
First version: 28 Nov 2006. Latest revision: 10 Dec 2006.

Question(s):
Why do many anorectics think they are fat when they are very thin?


Answer:


It can be said that we have two bodies: one that others can see and one that we think we have. Consequently, we can be fat and believe that we are thin and therefore don't need to reduce. Or, we can be like teenage Karin who only weighed 28 kg when she cried to her therapist that she was too fat and must slim!

Many people with eating disorders think they are fat when they have eaten too much or when they feel anxiety.

When calm and relaxed, they might see themselves more realistically. Their starvation is a continual risk factor for a compulsive eating attack. They know that they might not stop eating and are afraid of losing control.

Fear of becoming fat can be experienced as being fat. Many people who have been thin as children continue to think of themselves as thin when adults, even if they are overweight. For overweight children, the opposite is true, even if they develop anorexia nervosa!

Eating disorder patients base their evaluation of themselves exclusively on their weight and body image.

They think that if they are thin enough they can face the challenges of life: find a partner, a satisfying job, have friends, and be admired.

This cognitive prejudice leads them to have non-stop problematic thoughts about their body (such as: "I have a swollen belly", "my legs are too fat", "I am a useless fat woman", " I have gained a kilo so today and tomorrow I have to refrain from food", "I am so fat that I disgust people", "I cannot weigh more than 40 Kg", etc.) and in time they are prone to become perfect obsessions.

In addition there is also the incapacity to evaluate the body image from an objective point of view.

For these reasons a lot of eating disorder patients reach underweight and malnutrition levels that can seem incredible, if you forget that their self-esteem corresponds to their capability to maintain their weight under strict control.

When you are a victim of this self vision, the whole situation of life, even things that have nothing to do with the body, can set people off worrying about the body and weight, causing anxiety and new attempts at further control.

To break this cognitive-behavioural vicious circle that exists between the unwell body image and the excessive importance that these patients give to the body and body image is one of the principal tasks of Eating disorder therapy.

There are indeed a range of techniques aimed at body restructuring that, linked to other therapeutic techniques, help patients to overcome contempt for their bodies and begin to love it again.

Excessively Slim Ideals is a Cause of Eating Disorders; Eating Disorders and Fashion Magazines

Written by: Gunborg Palme, certified psychologist and certified psychotherapist, teacher and tutor in psychotherapy. First version: 26 Nov 2006. Latest revision: 26 Nov 2006.

Question
:
Can the current abnormal demands for slimness cause eating disorders?

Answer:
When beauty queens of former times and nowadays are compared it is obvious that they have become much slimmer. An appearance which was considered normal 50 years ago is rare today. In order to be as slim as fashion demands they are compelled to go around starving. Most women today feel that they are under an obligation to be slim. This results in an increasing number of them getting eating disorders.

Anorexia often begins with an attempt to be slimmer. Bulimia nervosa develops in 50 % of former anorectics when they can't manage to restrain their eating anymore.

Food containing a lot of sugar and fat dominate the market and if eaten regularly they soon cause an increase in weight. A person can get problems with self-image and eating through ideals which are spread by mass media. Many young women with a normal body shape get the idea that they are overweight and start slimming even though it is harmful for them.

In ancient China they bound the feet of young girls in order to prevent their feet growing to normal size and as a result they became invalids.